Alienware Sued For False Advertising Over Upgradeable Laptop That Wasn’t


This web page may receive affiliate commissions from the backlinks on this website page. Conditions of use.


At CES 2019, Alienware created a stunning announcement. The company’s then-new Location-51m gaming laptop computer wouldn’t just be a standard boutique refresh. The new system could be upgraded in the long run, in a method and diploma diverse than regular laptops.

Then, about 16 months later, Alienware backtracked. Instantly we have been instructed that the Spot-51m could only be upgraded with components offered when the technique was requested. The Space-51m, in other text, was not really upgradeable in any particular or special way at all. Now, Alienware has been sued for what the plaintiff claims is wrong marketing. Searching back at Alienware’s precise statements about the Area-51m, it’s really hard not to truly feel like the plaintiff has a place.

Robert Felter has submitted a class-motion lawsuit, shared with ExtremeTech, versus Dell in the Northern District of California, arguing that the firm “intentionally misled and deceived the public in purchase to develop a aggressive gain based mostly on false representation to strengthen profits of its flagship gaming notebook, the Alienware Place 51M R1.” He is represented by Brian Mahany, David Kani & Steve Hochfelsen.

Bait and Swap

In its CES announcement, Alienware claimed that the Place-51m was “the very first real desktop substitution.” Here’s Alienware’s January 8 2019 PR:

Practically 20 decades immediately after Alienware launched the initially gaming laptop computer with upgradeable graphics, garnered praise for its performance and went on to garner numerous awards, the organization is very pleased to launch its next flagship notebook with upgradeable graphics and processors.(Emphasis additional)

In case you missed it, the corporation repeats the “upgradeable” part once more, instantly under. “The reimagined Area-51m is the most effective, upgradeable gaming laptop ever conceived. It marks the 1st and only notebook with a 9th Gen 8-core desktop processors, 64GB2 of memory, two.5Gbps Ethernet technological innovation, upgradeable graphics and desktop processors, and 17” Alienware laptop with a slim-bezel show with 144Hz.” (Emphasis added).

The Verge had a glowing writeup of the Alienware Spot-51m prepared to go correct out of the gate. The subhed of the tale reads: “The ‘world’s most highly effective gaming laptop’ wishes to provide person-replaceable processors, graphics playing cards, storage, and RAM to transportable computer systems.” The Spot-51m is reported to address the two fundamental issues of laptop gaming: Practical sperm counts A absence of powerful factors in major-stop programs and the actuality that laptops cannot be upgraded.

The Verge writes:

A lot more importantly, in contrast to nearly just about every other gaming laptop out there, the Area-51m is created to allow you swap not only the really hard push, RAM and battery, but the CPU and GPU, too.

It’s not just lip company: Alienware is significant about allowing end users acquire this factor apart just like they would a complete-fledged desktop, down to easily detachable screws and labeled guides imprinted into the frame of the notebook to help you through disassembly or reassembly (which includes specs for each and every screw ought to you drop monitor of one particular alongside the way). There are pull tabs to enable you eliminate the laptop’s sensitive cables by hand, devoid of harmful them, and it reveals you the precise purchase you will need to flip the screws for the substantial CPU / GPU cooler to thoroughly torque it down.

In the context of establishing how Alienware communicated about this laptop computer, these information subject. The company didn’t launch a PR with a vague reference to potential updates. It declared that upgradeability was central to the product or service and gave journalists a deep dive into all the thoughtful means the technique was built to assistance entrepreneurs by means of the improve procedure.

The 1,719-term Verge tale inevitably reveals that Dell may possibly or could possibly not launch fresh new GPUs for the Area-51m, based on program gross sales and vendor help. This crucial information is buried some 800 words and phrases deep in the tale, and it isn’t disclosed in Alienware’s press release at all.

There is no info in the Verge story implying that CPU updates may possibly not be supported we elevated that ourselves when we wrote the news up. Alienware was not speaking that to would-be consumers at all, even however it presented a critical, noticeable issue in January 2019. Intel, traditionally, does not assist platforms for additional than one particular update cycle. ninth Gen chips like the Main i9-9900K experienced now replaced CPUs like the eighth Gen Main i7-8700K as Intel’s flagship.

Alienware clearly pulled out all the stops to sell the plan that this laptop computer would be a true upgradeable product. The “Oh, but it may not operate out,” was presented as a CYA minute alternatively than a really serious expectation when the enterprise spoke to push.

The complaint is straightforward: Alienware took benefit of how ardently laptop players want upgradeable laptops by pretending it would offer a person. It afterwards abandoned these statements, right after prospects picked an Alienware in excess of a distinctive method they might have selected rather.

Dell chose to marketplace this machine as upgradeable, realizing that customers would recognize that to signify “I can set a CPU or GPU in the device that was not available on the day the laptop computer released.” Desktop replacement PCs have existed for decades. The concept that the Area-51m was a “true” desktop replacement hinged on the concept that you could swap the CPU and GPU out for some thing new.

What’s particularly damning is that Alienware did not bother updating conclude consumers that their methods would not be upgradeable right up until May possibly 2020, very long immediately after Space-51m units experienced begun delivery to customers. As an OEM, Alienware would have recognized that Intel would shift to LGA 1200 for 10th Gen lengthy ahead of Intel confirmed it publicly, and information of LGA 1200 had leaked by July 2019.

I’m not likely to fake I know what took place. Maybe Alienware genuinely had the best of intentions. Perhaps the folks who have been backing the Space-51m upgradeable idea still left the organization. Irrespective, this was one of the even worse bait-and-switches we have witnessed a tech business pull. It’ll be exciting to see how Alienware defends alone and its use of the phrase “upgradeable” in these contexts.

Now Read:

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.